Tuck Everlasting runs May 7-9, 2021. Tickets go on sale February 2!
| In order of appearance | |
| Jesse Tuck | Caiden Garcia |
| Mae Tuck | Catelyn Lawrence |
| Miles Tuck | Samuel Ea |
| Angus Tuck | Eyan Choate |
| Winnie Foster | Anna Hahn |
| Mother | Elizabeth Perrone |
| Man In Yellow Suit | Malachi Havens |
| Nana | Kendall Cousins |
| Hugo | Joshua Patterson |
| Constable Joe | Jefferson Schonhoff |
| Ensemble | |
| Samuel Boyd | |
| Abbie Brown | |
| Isabella Brown | |
| Daniel Burks; Miles Tuck Understudy – | |
| Tentative performance on May 14 | |
| Kendall Cousins | |
| Callie Disch | |
| Abigail Dunn | |
| Andrew Dunn | |
| Sydney Dyer | |
| Emily Glover | |
| Stephen Harden | |
| Grace Henington | |
| Grace Jackson | |
| Ben Jacob | |
| Avery Lytle | |
| Elizabeth Grace Mainor | |
| William Mantzel | |
| Tristen Nelson | |
| David Nevils | |
| Kaylee Newell | |
| Joshua Patterson | |
| Jayne Pecena | |
| Elizabeth Perrone | |
| Lya Peterson | |
| Rylee Polk | |
| Sara Quartaro | |
| Sophia Quartaro | |
| Jonathan Rizzo | |
| Jefferson Schonhoff | |
| Olivia Smith | |
| Aislyn Standifer | |
| Emma Stever | |
| Layla Sullivan | |
| Abbie Sutton | |
| Micah Thompson | |
| Riley Unterbug | |
| Virginia Waterman | |
| Genevieve Welch | |
| Juliet Welch | |
| Tabitha Welch | |
| Ballet Casting | |
| Teen Winnie | Grace Henington |
| Young Adult Winnie | Jayne Pecena |
| Older Winnie | Juliet Welch |
| Young Adult Hugo | Andrew Dunn |
| Older Hugo | Ben Jacob |
